Student Loan Interest Caps Could Fuel the College Debt Crisis

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and other congressional Democrats have supported proposals to lower federal student loan interest rates, even as college tuition continues to rise. Lower interest rates would reduce repayment costs, but they would do little to address the tuition increases that have left millions of Americans with substantial student debt.
The Working Families Tax Cuts take a different approach by limiting federal graduate student borrowing and encouraging colleges to control tuition. Rather than simply making expensive degrees easier to finance, the law seeks to prevent students from accumulating excessive debt in the first place.
College Tuition Has Outpaced Overall Inflation
According to economist Mark J. Perry's updated "Chart of the Century," college tuition and fees increased 196.7% between January 2000 and December 2025, compared with overall inflation of 92.6%. Average hourly wages rose 131.1%, while college textbook prices increased 176.9%.
Federal student lending has helped finance these rising costs, but unrestricted borrowing can weaken incentives for colleges to control tuition. When students can borrow enough to cover virtually any price, universities face less pressure to keep their programs affordable.
Lowering interest rates may reduce repayment expenses, but students remain responsible for the principal they borrow.
The Working Families Tax Cuts Limit Excessive Borrowing
The Working Families Tax Cuts established new federal graduate borrowing limits and eliminated new Graduate PLUS loans beginning in July 2026, subject to transitional protections for certain existing students. Graduate PLUS previously allowed eligible students to borrow up to the full cost of attendance.
Graduate students generally face annual borrowing limits of $20,500 and an aggregate graduate limit of $100,000. Students in qualifying professional degree programs face limits of $50,000 annually and $200,000 overall.
These restrictions encourage universities to reconsider tuition prices that previously depended on unrestricted federal lending. Colleges seeking to maintain enrollment may need to reduce tuition, increase institutional financial aid, or improve the financial value of their degree programs.
Colleges Are Beginning to Respond
Early evidence suggests that some universities are adjusting their prices in response to the new borrowing limits.
As CFE previously reported in "Student Loan Caps and Fewer Freshmen Force Colleges to Face Reality," the University of California, Irvine announced a $30,000 tuition reduction for its Flex MBA program, lowering the price to $99,000, just below the new $100,000 aggregate graduate borrowing limit.
Other institutions have announced tuition reductions or additional financial aid as they prepare for the elimination of Graduate PLUS lending. Although it remains too early to determine whether these changes will produce a nationwide slowdown in tuition growth, they demonstrate how borrowing restrictions can influence college pricing decisions.
Interest Rate Caps Leave Tuition Costs Untouched
Proposals to cap federal student loan interest rates at 2%, or eliminate interest entirely, would provide savings to borrowers without directly reducing tuition.
The College Investor recently examined these proposals, illustrating how a student repaying a $30,000 loan over 10 years would pay substantially less interest at 2% than at the higher rates charged on many federal loans.
However, the borrower would still owe the original $30,000. If tuition continues increasing, future students could accumulate even larger balances despite paying lower interest rates.
Subsidizing borrowing costs without reasonable lending limits could further weaken incentives for colleges to control prices. Universities would continue collecting tuition while students and taxpayers assume the financial consequences of excessive borrowing.
Federal borrowing limits place greater responsibility on colleges to make their programs affordable, although some students may need alternative financing or less expensive educational options.
CFE Takeaway
Federal student loan policy should address the rising cost of college rather than concentrating exclusively on repayment expenses.
The Working Families Tax Cuts established borrowing limits that encourage universities to control tuition and reduce their reliance on unrestricted federal financing. Early tuition reductions and additional institutional financial aid suggest that some colleges are responding.
Interest rate caps may provide borrowers with relief, but preventing excessive student debt requires stronger incentives for colleges to control costs. The Working Families Tax Cuts offer an opportunity to improve affordability before students spend decades repaying loans for degrees that should have cost less in the first place.




Comments