top of page

Congress Should Extend the College Endowment Tax to Wealthy Tax-Exempt Hospitals

2 hours ago
4 min read

Congress already taxes the investment income of wealthy private universities such as Harvard and Yale. A similar tax on the financial investments of large tax-exempt hospitals could generate billions in federal revenue while addressing the preferential tax treatment enjoyed by some of the nation's wealthiest nonprofit institutions.


The Tax Foundation recently examined options for reforming the taxation of large tax-exempt hospital systems, including extending the type of net investment income tax that Congress established for wealthy private universities. With major hospital systems holding substantial investment portfolios, lawmakers have an opportunity to apply an existing tax policy more broadly as part of revenue-neutral tax reform that offsets the additional revenue with tax relief elsewhere in the economy.


Congress Established a Precedent With University Endowments


The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 established a 1.4% excise tax on the net investment income of certain wealthy private colleges and universities. The Working Families Tax Cuts expanded that policy in 2025, creating a graduated tax structure with rates of 1.4%, 4%, and 8%, depending on an institution's endowment assets relative to its student enrollment.


The higher rates apply to institutions with the largest endowments per student, including some of the nation's wealthiest universities. Harvard has estimated that its annual endowment tax liability could increase by approximately $300 million under the revised law.


The tax applies to investment earnings, including interest, dividends, and realized capital gains, rather than the universities' educational operating revenue. These institutions retain their tax-exempt status while paying federal taxes on qualifying investment income.


Recent endowment returns demonstrate the financial resources available to elite universities. The Committee to Unleash Prosperity highlighted investment returns of approximately 26% at Yale and 23% at Princeton, illustrating the substantial earnings that can accumulate within tax-exempt institutions.


Congress has already recognized that large nonprofit investment portfolios can be subject to federal taxation without eliminating the underlying tax exemption. The same approach deserves consideration for large tax-exempt hospital systems.


Large Tax-Exempt Hospitals Have Accumulated Significant Investment Wealth


Tax-exempt hospitals benefit from exemptions from federal corporate income taxes, state and local property taxes, and other tax advantages. In exchange, they are expected to provide community benefits, including charity care and other qualifying services.


Many large hospital systems have accumulated substantial financial reserves and investment portfolios alongside their healthcare operations. These assets can generate significant investment income that generally remains exempt from federal income taxation.


According to the Tax Foundation, 2,271 hospital filers collectively reported approximately $1.8 trillion in assets, $1.4 trillion in revenue, and $87.9 billion in net income in 2024.


The federal tax advantages available to these institutions are considerable. Research examined by the Tax Foundation estimates that the federal corporate income tax exemption alone provides hospitals with approximately $8.3 billion to $11.5 billion in annual tax benefits, depending on the year and methodology.


Hospitals require financial reserves to support operations, fund capital improvements, and respond to unexpected expenses. However, the scale of investment holdings at some of the largest hospital systems raises questions about whether all of their investment earnings should continue receiving preferential federal tax treatment.


A Hospital Investment Income Tax Could Generate Billions


The Tax Foundation examined the potential revenue from applying an excise tax on net investment income to large tax-exempt hospital systems, using the university endowment tax as a model.


Under the proposal, the tax would apply to hospital systems with average annual revenue exceeding $1 billion over the preceding three years. The Tax Foundation estimates that approximately 287 systems would meet this threshold in 2027, representing the overwhelming majority of the sector's revenue, income, and assets.


A 4% tax on net investment income could generate approximately $22.8 billion in federal revenue over ten years, while an 8% rate could raise $45.6 billion. Applying a 21% rate, equivalent to the federal corporate income tax rate, could generate approximately $119.6 billion over the same period.


The 4% and 8% options would align with the higher rates already established for wealthy university endowments. Limiting the tax to large hospital systems would concentrate the policy on institutions with substantial financial resources while generally excluding smaller community hospitals.


These estimates provide a starting point for evaluating the proposal, although actual revenue would depend on the final tax structure and how hospital systems respond.


Reforming Investment Taxes Through Revenue-Neutral Tax Reform


Extending an investment income tax to large tax-exempt hospitals should be part of a broader revenue-neutral tax reform effort rather than a standalone federal tax increase. Any additional revenue collected from hospital investment earnings should be used to offset reductions in other taxes, preserving the overall federal tax burden while improving the structure of the tax code.


Such an approach would allow Congress to reduce preferential treatment for large nonprofit investment portfolios while supporting lower taxes on work, saving, and investment elsewhere in the economy.


The proposal would address a specific tax preference without subjecting all hospital operating revenue to the federal corporate income tax. Hospitals must maintain adequate reserves to finance medical equipment, facility improvements, and ongoing patient care. A properly structured excise tax could preserve the tax treatment of qualifying healthcare operations while applying a federal tax to certain investment earnings.


Congress would need to consider how the tax applies to different types of investment income, whether particular reserves should receive special treatment, and how to avoid discouraging investments necessary for patient care.


The Tax Foundation examined other approaches to hospital tax reform, including applying the corporate income tax to large hospital systems. An investment income excise tax would represent a more targeted option, building on a framework Congress has already adopted for wealthy private universities.


CFE Takeaway


Congress has established a precedent for taxing investment income earned by wealthy tax-exempt universities. Large tax-exempt hospital systems, many of which hold substantial financial investments, warrant consideration under a similar framework.


The Tax Foundation estimates that a 4% to 8% excise tax on the net investment income of large hospital systems could generate approximately $22.8 billion to $45.6 billion over ten years. Such a policy would focus on investment earnings while preserving the underlying tax exemption for qualifying hospital operations.


Congress should pursue this reform as part of a revenue-neutral tax package that uses the proceeds to reduce other taxes rather than increase the overall federal tax burden. Extending the university endowment tax model to large tax-exempt hospitals would provide an opportunity to eliminate preferential tax treatment while supporting a more efficient, pro-growth federal tax code.

 
 
 

Comments


Join our mailing list

  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
CFE logo.png

© 2026 Center for a Free Economy

bottom of page